| 
 There’s a special glow this holiday season at Cape May’s First Presbyterian 
Church. 
The congregation is celebrating the restoration of the church’s 110-year-old 
stained glass windows. Thirty five windows, including massive 17-by-17 foot 
Gothic arches, have been painstakingly, lovingly, professionally reworked. The 
antique art glass was saved, while repainting and releadin g new pieces in the 
brilliant colors and fine hand-painted features that make the windows so 
special. The work is similar to resetting thousands of pieces of rare gems in 
custom-designed jewelry, but on a massive scale.  
It was just two years ago that Dick and Dixie Barab met with 11 church members 
to discuss the worsening condition of the windows, and what to do about saving 
them. 
Located at Hughes and Decatur streets, just a couple blocks from the sea, and 
stressed by a century of storms, the windows suffered severe cracking and 
bowing. The antique paint was flaking, the lead deteriorating and the wooden 
frames were weakened by invading termites.  
The concerned church members called their mission Save Our Stained Glass 
 
 Windows. They learned the windows were created by Wilheim (William) Reith, born 
in Baden-Baden, Germany, in 1844, arriving in America in 1867 at age 23. His 
studio was located at 134 North 7th Street in Philadelphia.  
The windows he designed for the Cape May church depict scenes from 
the life Christ and stories from the Bible. The glass was painted with brilliant 
reds, golds, purples, greens and blues with generous amounts of silver stain. 
The paint was composed of ground glass, metallic oxide coloring agents and flux 
to lower the temperature of the glass when melted.  
The brilliant art windows struck awe and inspiration among congregants at the 
first service in the new stone Gothic-style First Presbyterian Church, held May 
21st, 1899. And now, almost 110 years later, these same restored windows filter 
the light of the sun and the reflection of the sea 
 
 upon members and visitors at 
religious services, theatrical and musical events. The church has a cultural 
mission offering monthly Jazz Vespers and is home to most performances of the 
East Lynne Theatre Company.  
For Dottie Rogers, Cape May’s First Lady of stained glass, the completed 
restoration is a victory of a lifetime. She is on the committee to save the 
windows. A retired school teacher and resident of West Cape May, Dottie’s goal 
is to photograph every stained glass window on Cape Island. In five years, she 
has organized almost 2,000 photos of stained glass 
windows, their histories and 
locations on her computer. And she’s always looking for more.  
 Jewels of Cape May
Dottie says a small town like Cape May is unique to have such a variety of 
stained glass. She explains “the great fire of 1878 destroyed so many structures 
that in the aftermath, there was a giant building boom in the Victorian era when 
stained glass was very popular in America.” During this period, Americans 
developed an appetite and appreciation for this art form. Architects and 
builders eagerly installed stained glass into homes, churches and public 
buildings. Dottie’s most recent photos show the process of restoring the stained 
glass windows at her church. 
The window restoration committee chose the J&R Lamb Studio in Clifton, New 
Jersey, to bring new life to the Reith windows. Lamb is the oldest continuously 
 
 operating stained glass studio in the United States.  
Don Samick, owner, says that the Reith windows were a challenge because of 
the great amount of fading paint. First these fragile giants needed to be 
removed, loaded on a truck and transported to the studio. There each window is 
cleaned (“just with water,” says Samick), evaluated, disassembled and laid out 
like pieces of a puzzle. Detailed rubbings are made of each layer of glass. 
Artists recreate faded and damaged colors and images to their original 
brilliance and detail. Those new pieces are fired and then laminated in double 
leading beneath the antique glass so that you see through the original glass 
into the more brilliant restored glass, all blending seamlessly into one vision. 
“When we arrived at Lamb,” says Dottie, “several of our windows were laid out 
in pieces on tables, lead gone and pinned.” It took a leap of faith that the 
artists could put these precious antiques back together again. “We had done our 
homework 
 
 picking a studio,” says Dottie. “We had no fear.”  
The restored panels were reassembled and transported back to the church for 
installation. The windows are trucked at 75-degree angles, between Styrofoam 
pads, secured with straps. The large mural windows are held in place at the 
church with steel T-bars anchored in the wood frames.  
All of this was accomplished over 13 months and at the cost of $206,000. 
Meanwhile back at the church, the committee members were busy elves coming up 
with inventive ways to raise the money.  
A special Jazz Vespers was held to benefit the restoration project. Local 
world-class jazz musicians, pianist George Mesterhazy and singer Lois Smith, 
contributed their talents. The event raised $15,000. The church members hosted 
bake and yard sales and Fornight Feasting dinners, card parties, a July 4th 
barbecue. Christmas bazaar profits went t o the windows. The East Lynne Theatre 
Company donated a production’s proceeds.  
The most productive idea came from Bruce Jeffries-Fox and his wife Zan who 
created a price-per-window list for purchase by a sponsor. ”Whether a person 
contributed $1 or $1,000,” says Dottie, “every one will be acknowledged.” 
Among the contributors is Lamb Studio itself. Don Samick, his artists and 
craftsmen gifted the church with a window over the Decatur Street entry. “It’s 
just a small piece of gratitude for a wonderful project,” says Samick. By the 
way, the Cape May spirit has captured Samick and his wife Donna. They were 
frequent B&B guests, but recently have purchased a home of their own in Cape 
May. The Presbyterian congregation couldn’t be happier than to have their 
stained glass artist in residence. “The windows will be good for another 150 
years!” says he.  
 
  
	About Stained Glass
	References to stained glass reach back to the 4th and 5th centuries, the art 
form reaching its peak in the 10th – 13th centuries, especially in cathedrals. 
Glass was colored by adding metallic salts while in a molten state: copper to 
produce green, cobalt for blue, gold to create red, silver nitrate to color 
yellow from pale lemon to deep orange.  
	The colored glass is crafted into stained glass windows in which small pieces 
of glass arranged to form patterns or pictures are held together by strips of 
lead or copper and supported by a rigid frame. The term stained glass also is 
used to describe windows in which all the colors have been painted onto the 
glass and then made permanent with heat.  
	Stained glass creation is both an art and a craft requiring the artistic 
skill to develop the design and the engineering skills to assemble the 
decorative piece be it a window, lamp shade, or free hanging art piece. In the 
case of a window it must be constructed to support its own weight and survive 
the elements sometimes for hundreds of years.  
	Religious conflicts and wars destroyed many complex stained glass windows 
over the centuries in Europe, Asia and the Middle East.  
	The most prolific stained glass period in America was in the Victorian era 
from the 1850s to the 1920s. 
  
Text by Karen Fox. Photographs by Dottie Rogers. The original article, 
Jewels of Cape May, first appeared in 
Cape May Magazine, Winter 2007. 
   |