Shopping in Cape May

Cape May Peanut Butter Co.

When you not only like, but LOVE peanut butter, then the Cape May Peanut Butter Company is a must-stop location. Not only do we carry our gourmet nut butters and peanut butter themed goods of all kinds, but we also grind fresh nut butters right in store and offer a nutty abundance of bakery items. Try one of our peanut butter cannolis, fresh baked cookies, scones, brownies and much, Much more! Did we mention we have ice cream sandwiches and peanut butter beverages as well? Stop in for the perfect gift, try one of our insanely scrumptious baked goods or sample some of our fresh nut butters to find your new favorite.

And when the warm aromas of fresh baked brownies and cookies create the urge to indulge, you can heed the call by enjoying your treats in our beautiful courtyard seating area, or bag them up and take them to the beach with you. Pets are also welcome in our open-air courtyard, and they’ll love our treats just as much as you — we have plenty of peanut butter treats for dogs, too!


Cape May Peanut Butter Co. sells