Shopping in Cape May

Gift Shops

  1. Across the Way

    We specialize in many unique gifts and items for the home.

  2. Cape May Artists Co-Op Gallery

    The place for local art. Its 18 members are inspired by the beauty of the area and their work reflects it.

  3. Cape May Bird Observatory

    Optics, accessories, book, clothing, gifts and more… in stores & online!

  4. Cape May Cigars & Wine

    Established in 2004 Cape May Cigars & Wine offers a walk in humidor and an eclectic collection of the fine Cigars & Wines. Enjoy Free Tastings of our local wines. A must do when visiting beautiful Cape May!

  5. Cape May Gourmet

    315 Ocean Street Cape May, NJ 08204 (609) 898-8500 Visit us on Facebook

  6. Cape May Olive Oil Co.

    Gourmet olive oils, balsamic vinegars, natural sea salts, organic spices, and pure cane sugars

  7. Cape May Peanut Butter Co.

    A great experience for the peanut butter lover! Fresh nut butters ground in-store.

  8. Cape May Soap Co.

    We are a small soap-making studio that turns natural ingredients into fine artisan quality bath & body products.

  9. Cape May Sports Memorabilia

    High quality sports cards & memorabilia at reasonable prices.

  10. Cape Winds Florist

    We are family owned and operated with over 30 Years experience. We are committed to offering only the finest floral arrangements and gifts, backed by service that is friendly and prompt.

  11. Celebrate Cape May

    Cape May T-shirts, sweat, and children’s clothing, jewelry, magnets, shot glasses, wine glasses, coffee mugs even piggy banks, spoon rests, car decals and more.

  12. Dellas 5 & 10

    501-503 Washington Street

  13. Fathoms

    at South Jersey Marina 1232 Route 109 Cape May, NJ 08204

  14. Great White Shark

    Great White Shark carries one-of-a-kind Cape May sweatshirts, t-shirts, & caps, plus gifts for everyone, from car decals to beach jewelry. We have sizes ranging from S to 6X. We also carry children’s sizes.

  15. Little Jewelry Shop by the Sea

    We offer unique fashion and fine jewelry crafted by American artisans along with accessories and gifts. Come by and find your treasure by the sea!

  16. Love the Cook

    If you (or someone you adore) like to be in the kitchen, you’ve come to the right place!
    Everything you need to create the contents of a dream kitchen is available here with the click of a mouse!

  17. Madame’s Port Cape May

    Thoughtfully selected gifts, jewelery, hats, knickknacks and more. Come stop by and see all we have to offer!

  18. Out of the Past Antiques

    Find the things you had forgotten and take them home with you! Out of the Past Antiques is full of fond memories and small surprises!

  19. Queen May Estate Jewelry

    Offering a curated collection of jewelry from the past to be worn in the present, Queen May specializes in fine estate jewelry, antique jewelry, rings and engagement rings.

  20. Sea Bags

    103 Liberty Place, 507 Washington Street Mall Cape May, New Jersey, 08204 (207) 939-1202

  21. SOMA NewArt Gallery

    Cape May’s metropolitan-style gallery.

  22. Stitch by Stitch

    Stitch by Stitch is headquarters for Cape May and Victorian cross stitch and needle work designs.

  23. Sunset Beach Gift Shops

    In our main gift shop we have a great selection of souvenirs and collectibles for your browsing and shopping convenience. We are world-renowned for our Cape May Diamond collection, but we also have many other unique items.

  24. Tea by the Sea

    Located in Victorian Cape May, NJ we have all of your tea and tea party needs. We carry over 350 blends of tea, a full line of fine china, candles, and gift items.

  25. Uniquely Yours

    Our women’s clothing store and bridal boutique shop provides romantic era inspired attire and accessories for encore weddings, vow renewals and making every day feel like a special occasion.

  26. Valentino’s Coins

    Valentino’s is a family owned business where ethics and integrity go hand in hand with every transaction. Specializing in Rare Coins, Fine Jewelry, Antiques, Collectibles, Estate Liquidations and Military & Historical Artifacts.

  27. Victorious

    Abundant collection of Antique and Estate Jewelry. Unique collection of contemporary designer jewelry. Go upstairs for all the eye candy a girl could want. Clothing, shoes, handbags, accessories, gifts and so much more.

  28. Whale’s Tale

    For 30 years, we have sold hand-crafted jewelry, soaps and fragrances, kids’ toys and books, specimen sea shells, and a large assortment of cards and paper goods.