In response to New Jersey’s COVID-19 pandemic guidelines, Cape May is opening businesses and services gradually. Learn more

Dining in Cape May


Get excited to dine in our restaurant, on the Porch, or in the newly expanded Phinney’s Pub, where our culinary staff works hard to deliver the freshest ingredients and finest cocktail options Cape May has to offer.

Plus, we offer Cape May’s only dinner theatre experience.  Prepare to be thoroughly entertained this show season with an all new professional theater line-up. Elaine’s Famous Dinner Theater has been voted one of the Top 5 Dinner Theaters in America by the Food Network. Combining this prestigious award with our first class restaurant fare, your evening out will impress any critic.

Our professional and friendly staff serves our guests dinner, appetizers, and drinks throughout the Show. Phinney’s Pub – our inside bar – will be open at 5pm before the show. Theater seating begins at 6:30pm for 8pm Shows. Theater seating for 1:30pm shows begin at 12pm.

Elaine’s offers: