Gifts & Souvenirs

A Place on Earth

By bringing soap making into the twenty-first century, we are reviving a lost art form, steeped in tradition.

Full info Open Year-Round, Call for hours.
Cape Atlantic Book Co

We are a full-service independent bookstore located in historic Victorian Cape May, New Jersey.

Full info Open Year-Round, Call for hours.
Cape May Bird Observatory

Optics, accessories, book, clothing, gifts and more… in stores & online!

Full info Open Year-Round, Call for hours.
Cape May Cigars & Wine

Offering a walk in humidor and an eclectic collection of fine cigars & wines.

Full info Open year-round. Call for hours.
Cape May Olive Oil Co.

Gourmet olive oils, balsamic vinegars, natural sea salts, organic spices, and pure cane sugars

Full info Open year-round. Call for hours.
Cape May Peanut Butter Co.

A great experience for the peanut butter lover! Fresh nut butters ground in-store.

Full info Open Year-Round, Call for hours.
Cape May Sports Memorabilia

High quality sports cards & memorabilia at reasonable prices.

Full info Open Year-Round, Call for hours.
Cape May Wicker

Cape May Wicker features the largest showroom of patio furniture.

Full info Both locations:
Open 9 am - 5 pm
7 days a week
Cape May Winery
Cape May Winery

Our wine shop is open daily.

Full info Open year-round. Call for hours.
Cheese Shop – Cape May Creamery

Cape May’s hot new cheese and charcuterie boutique has arrived. Cheese boards, charcutier boards and all things cheese.

Full info Open Year-Round, Call for hours.
Collier’s Liquor Store

Our famous wine selection has received acclaim from The New York Times. We can supply wine, beer, soda, liquor, ice, and cups for parties and large groups.

Full info Open Year-Round, Call for hours.
Elaine's Boutique
Elaine’s Boutique

A large variety of high-quality fashion for men and women, there is something in store for every customer!

Full info Open year-round. Please call for hours.
Fathoms

A fresh approach to coastal clothing and gifts in Cape May, New Jersey. Our store features national brands as well as local artisans.

Full info Open in-season.
GIVENS front window
GIVENS

GIVENS is the result of our desire to create a space dedicated to our ever-growing circle of artists, designers, & creatives.  

Full info Open year-round. Call for hours.
Great White Shark

One-of-a-kind Cape May sweatshirts, t-shirts, & caps, plus gifts for everyone, from car decals to beach jewelry! Sizes ranging from S to 6X. We also carry children’s sizes.

Full info Winter Hours:
Mon – Sun 10-4
Green Street Market

All natural, healthy, fresh and delicious whole foods specializing in organic, non-GMO, locally grown and fair trade certified products

Full info Open year-round. Call for hours
Happy Baby Collective

A unique handpicked collection of organic, heirloom, and stylish clothing. 

Full info
Hawk Haven Winery

Located on a sprawling 100+ acre farm. Visit us every day for wine tastings and wines by the glass/bottle.

Full info Open year-round. Call for hours.
Love the Cook

House roasted coffee, loose leaf tea, spices, oils, mustards, salad dressings, kitchen accessories and gadgets, as well as a selection of cookbooks.

Full info Open Year-Round, Call for hours.
Out of the Past Antiques

Find the things you had forgotten and take them home with you! Out of the Past Antiques is full of fond memories and small surprises!

Full info Hours by Chance
Payton Jewelry

Cape May’s Charm Bar & Permanent Jewelry Destination!

Full info
Pour | Candle Bar & Chandlery

Enjoy a self-guided DIY soy candle experience!

Full info Call for hours.
Stitch by Stitch store interior
Stitch by Stitch

Stitch by Stitch is headquarters for Cape May and Victorian cross stitch and needle work designs.

Full info
Sunset Beach Gift Shop
Sunset Beach Gift Shops

In our main gift shop we have a great selection of souvenirs and collectibles for your browsing and shopping convenience.

Full info Open year-round! Check Facebook for current hours
Sunshine-Daydream

A beachy bohemian vibe and carry a unique selection of jewelry, gifts, clothing, and accessories including bridal accessories.

Full info Both locations open year-round.
Visit our website for current hours.
Lighthouse museum shop
The Museum Shops

Cape May MAC offers three gift shops: the Carriage House at the Emlen Physick Estate, the Cape May lighthouse museum shop, and the World War II Lookout Tower museum shop.

Full info
Thread & Root

Women’s clothing, shoes & accessories.

Full info Open seasonally
Tommys Folly Boutique

Make sure to put Tommy’s Folly Boutique on your Cape May “must-do” list. Located on the corner of Carpenters Lane & Perry Street, this stylish boutique is a fashion lover’s paradise and features sophisticated resort wear and accessories from both established designers and up-and-coming talent.

Full info Open year-round. See website for hours.
West End Garage

Check out antique furniture and accessories, vintage memorabilia, artwork from local and regional artisans, estate jewelry, and more. This is a gift-shopping paradise; you can find unique gifts for the most discriminating person.

Full info Open Year-Round, Call for hours.
Whale’s Tale

For 30 years, we have sold hand-crafted jewelry, soaps and fragrances, kids’ toys and books, specimen sea shells, and a large assortment of cards and paper goods.

Full info Open Year-Round, Call for hours.